Jump to content

STEMedTeacher

Dormant
  • Posts

    30
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by STEMedTeacher

  1. I had my Computer Aided Design students do the Starter Round yesterday. I think the framework is great. Ambiguous enough to get them thinking outside the box, but constrained enough to develop some focus on the idea. The class had a ton of fun doing it, looking forward to getting my hands on the full game.

    Here are some pictures and videos of my students working with it.

    IMG_1116.thumb.JPG.28f0a56a1251d70cbc1ae3864b8bf723.JPG

    IMG_1119.thumb.JPG.09f0c01e87c7eaa504a098471076416a.JPG

    IMG_1122.thumb.JPG.db801481a54a688c6cb9c9426cf87a9f.JPG

    IMG_1147.thumb.JPG.58c3431379046f3936873e8c64234809.JPG

    This was just our first run through, I am looking forward to seeing the full game.

    • Like 4
  2. I have a 2 Go and at the time went with a Titan extruder, Olsson Block, and a Print in Z build plate.

    I strongly recommend going with SOME kind of upgraded extruder. The stock one is just not reliable in my experience, the Medusa one on the GR5 store looks great and is nice and low cost. 2 to 1 ratio is nice. The Titan gives you 3 to 1, but its not like you would REALLY need that. I have no Bondtech experience to speak of but I do know they offer lots of filament control and as someone earlier mentioned zero issues with their prints.

    I will say that the Titan has had no problems once I got it set up properly for the filament.  I assume the same of the Medusa since it's essentially a + Extruder clone.

    Whatever extruder you do end up with you will need to go to the Tinkergnome firmware which is really easy to work with.  You  need to change the steps on the extruder so it will work properly.

    As for Olsson block and V3 blocks. I run the Olsson and really like it.  The V3 has multiple improvements to it, but I personally can't see them being a great bang for your buck.  

    Someone mentioned a 35W heater. I know that GR5 sells them and I really like heated beds on printers, but I will say from my experiences for the last two years printing on a Print in Z build plate almost daily it's been super reliable, parts stick very well (PLA) but I have never run anything but PLA on that machine.  If with these upgrades you want to run other materials, you may consider a heated bed.

    For what it's worth, I plan on picking up another 2 Go and doing the same modifications to it.  Not only because then I have the same things to upkeep, but I know they work well. Also I have not yet done the TFM upgrade but that is next on my list of things to do.

    Links to the other mentioned things were provided but here is the Print in Z plate if you are interested in taking a look at that too.

    http://www.printinz.com/printinz-3d-printer-plates/

  3. Hello,

    I would suggest looking at the Ultimaker Pioneer site, I am one of the Pioneers this year and we publish content that may be of some help to you. What kinds of things are you trying to get students engaged with? This idea is great, but it is quite expansive. Do you have any specific targets in mind, do you have a software you want them to use?

  4. Common vacuum forming.  Pretty light duty and limited usage I'd say.  I hope they aren't charging more than a $150.

     

    Yup... I doubt the setup can do anything other than what was shown in the video. Sure some people might find use of it but more likely it would be purchased, get used once or twice, and sit on a shelf. There are far more capable thermoformers out there for reasonable pricing or DIY setups.

  5.  

    Awesome work! How much larger is this compared to the factory 2+ head?  I assume the intent is to make an easier to swap nozzle that is better designed?

     

    I'll try to keep as much of the build size as possible, for now it looks like I might loose a bit in X and gain a bit in Z.

    My main intent is to be able to get the CORE quality in terms of usable temperature range to the UM2, but the easy swapping is ofc also nice. Be aware it comes with a cost, pricewise nothing beats changing a nozzle on an olsonblock.

     

    Any thoughts on implementing a flex drive with it?

  6.  

    Is it possible to release the work that was done so that the community may pick it up?

     

    The core problem was mechanical. And there was no easy fix we concluded after a lot of research. So releasing that has no real use other then wasting time. Electrically it was based on the AS5048B chip. So if you get out your soldering iron, you could still build this. Cables are still in place.

     

    Was the design integrated in anything or was it intended to be be a standalone component in the system?

  7. Nope, no sensor to check the material movement. It is one of the features that didn't make it. (it's "feature X") We had prototypes, you can encounter remains of it in the code. But we had reliability issues with the design. And we did not want to release something that wasn't reliable.

    The sensor was added because it is almost free. And in the future we can use it for better temperature control as well as potential warnings when you want to print with PVA and your room temperature is too hot.

     

    Is it possible to release the work that was done so that the community may pick it up?

  8. Here is a resource that may help you dial in issues.

    https://www.simplify3d.com/support/print-quality-troubleshooting/#blobs-and-zits

    Your temp might be a little low and you are trying to compensate in other areas that may effect print quality even more negatively... I would start with doing a smaller test print and start dialing in your printer settings.

    Have you done any small print testing like https://www.youmagine.com/designs/hollower-calibration-pyramid to try different settings?

  9. Ok, so I just typed out a huge response and while using my chromebook, hit post reply, and lost everything.... BAH

    Ok so back to it again, I think that terminology is most certainly an issue. For new comers who don't know the terminology they may use the search function inappropriately. For example someone may say "Thing in back of the machine" which will net them very few useful responses when they should look for "feeder"

    I think many people would benefit from some kind of startup academy, but the logistics of that are just insane to get to everyone across the world and to each potential Ultimaker customer. However, what if on the SD card that is shipped with each printer, rather than just the sample prints, you get a startup trainer? A little self launching program that can be used to teach people some of the beginning points of the printer. I would suggest a paper guide, but really most people don't even read those when they do have them. Everyone will use the SD card when they purchase a new machine, everyone will put it into a computer. Well unless they are a professional user buying more machines, in which case all they need to do is format the drive and go from there. This may be a potential way to encourage people to use the forums more for help too rather than get discouraged.

    This is just an idea, and if it were something that would be pursued, I would think that this could be a great place for Ultimaker Pioneers to help develop the tools needed for this new user experience.

    By doing this, you are giving support upon purchase and guidance of where to start and how to find help. While everyone may not use it, you have provided a service for those who do need this and want this to start with their machine to find success.

    Just an idea though. Also back to the topic of the forum, much of the mentioned ideas are good, one of the challenges are keeping the "professionals" around to help answer questions for the new people. As mentioned and seen across the forum, many answers are given by a few people across the board, which it is great that these people either from the Ultimaker team or outside are here to help, it is also taxing. Using some kind of "Hall of Fame" would be helpful, but people need to know what its about and how to use it. Getting information to people where they will see it is really important.

    Being a part of the Pioneer program I have learned a TON from my fellow pioneers. I teach engineering, so the uses for our machines are primarily function and strength of design. There are so many awesome opportunities I learned from art teachers, elementary teachers, math teachers etc. on using these tools in innovative ways. I think people will share their stories willingly. The challenge is how do you get the receiving end to see that and learn from others experiences.

    • Like 1
  10. SLA as a process is REALLY COOL! It has become more popularized due to companies like Formlabs, SprintRay, Carbon, etc. It makes great looking parts, but for the general user it is not a process that many would like to encounter. The post process cleanup is messy, the curing is potentially difficult, especially if you need a strong part, not something that most users would typically benefit from. Those who need this type of a solution, there are lots of great products already on the market as mentioned from companies above. So Carbon is out of normal mortals price range, but it is made for industry. Formlabs (Form 2) and SprintRay (MoonRay) are printers that are not too far off of a great UM2+ or UM3 machine.

    To get to the SLA market would mean a major shift in R&D as well which would potentially put their FDM machines in a state of holding for advancement which is no fun either. We all want to see newer and better Ultimaker FDM machines.

    • Like 1
  11. policies keep people from doing their jobs.  I don't like policies unless they are just guidelines and it's okay to ignore them if you have thought it through.

     

    HAHA! Welcome to the wacky world of education. This is common place for us, as sad as it may be, we typically have to work in envelopes created by others who are not educators themselves. The state policy makers typically are not teachers and have not taught before. The only way though it is having an administration who trusts and supports their educators to do what is in the best interest of students, this is not always the case though.

  12. Hello all. love the idea of a collaboration. For the education world, Ultimaker has the Pioneer program which I am one of 58 involved.  We are looking for ways to impact the education world in respect to 3d printing and getting more educators to understand the impact it can have on many areas of education.  I think this and the Pioneer program working together could give some good direction for both but it would take some key people coming to the proverbial table to talk about this and flesh out what it looks like in real life.

    I agree this forum is difficult to find information unless you know what to search for, and the suggestions above would help. Just a question though, is this the place that professionals go for information, or where new comers go for information?  I don't know what kind of traffic the forums get, but I would imagine that the number of Ultimakers sold does not accurately reflect the traffic on this site.  Any ideas as to why that is?

    • Like 1
×
×
  • Create New...