Well, my bed leveling is fine, plus I printed them almost next to each other as seen in the photo, the disparity between them is not caused by that. Also, I have tested printing the circle by itself individually in the exact same spot as the square circle and it comes out fine. Upon closer inspection of the print itself, it seems even though they are the same circle, the nozzle extrudes WAY more filament when printing for the circle inside of the square than outside. I can take a video if you want. I ended up fixing this by just printing the circle by itself and then keeping it on the bed and starting the new print on top of it which turned out fine.