"Select face to align to the build plate" doesn't quite align

[gauthier 0]

I love the idea behind "Select face to align to the build plate", but it doesn't seem to go all the way. I noticed that because the skirt on my print didn't go around the whole part, it went through the middle.

 

The model directly after opening:

 

After "Select face to align to the build plate", seen from below. The face is not completely red, only half of it seems to be touching the build plate:

 

After "Lay flat":

 

This is how I expect the downward face to look like after "Select face to align to the build plate".

 

Is this a known issue? Am I doing something wrong?

 

Cura 4.6.1

[ahoeben 1,320]

Can you post a link to the model, so we can try with your exact model?

[gauthier 0]

Here comes. I reported an issue on github too, I figured too late that it might be a better place to do it. Should we stop the discussion here and continue there, or the opposite?

[burtoogle 501]

I tried it a couple of times and it worked OK for me.

[burtoogle 501]

I just got a failure when I selected a face on one of the short arms rather than the longer piece. Perhaps the arms are very slightly wonky (technical term) ?

[gauthier 0]

oh, yeah! I realize now the thin faces were not really parallel! Sorry about that. I guess "Lay flat" chose the largest of the thin faces, and that's why it looked like it worked better.

 

I think it looks right for you @burtoogle, because it might depend on where you exactly click when selecting the face.

 

Still, I don't get that "Lay flat" managed to place all the "not really parallel" faces flat on the build plate anyway. It looks right after that.

Edited May 28, 2020 by gauthier

[burtoogle 501]

29 minutes ago, gauthier said:

I think it looks right for you @burtoogle, because it might depend on where you exactly click when selecting the face.

 

Exactly! Look at all the faces it has to choose from. Can you guarantee that they are all aligned horizontally?