UltiMaker uses functional, analytical and tracking cookies. Tracking cookies enhance your experience on our website and may also collect your personal data outside of Ultimaker websites. If you agree with the use of tracking cookies, click “I agree, continue browsing”. You can withdraw your consent at any time. If you do not consent with the use of tracking cookies, click “Refuse”. You can find more information about cookies on our Privacy and Cookie Policy page.
Okay, well...I unchecked the option to let the printer firmware override Cura's retraction settings during the filament change, and instead allowed Cura's default retraction settings to override the printer's---that seemed to solve the issue. I did notice if I just press the pause button and then press resume it does not go back to the same spot so I think it's just faulty printer firmware.