GregValiant, I sent you a PM, but thought others might benefit, so I'm posting it here again. Thanks.
After seeing other people's success printing the same R2D2 parts using PETG, I noticed one major difference... they all had direct drive extruders, or very short Bowden tubes. My Ender 6 has a very long (0.85m) Bowden tube. That might explain why small parts look great, but the large ones have issues. The large parts are flexing the Bowden tube quite a bit and with the flexible and stretchy PETG, the extrusion amount varies considerably. That would also explain why the different extrusion settings had little, or no, effect. That might also explain why the stiffer materials, like PLA, were less affected by the long Bowden tube.
What do you think?