A cautionary tale and an embarrassing error.
I am posting the answerto help others even though the mechs in our workshop are having a real fun time with the solution to this issue.
I mixed up the fan and capacitive sensor plugs, but the diag on the cap sensor still gave realistic readings through the coil of the fan 😞 which masked the error.
I won't excuse myself with justification but we all can mess up but...
In the rush to fit the new fan I forgot to take a picture of the connections in the rear, the capacitive sensor plug didn't want to go back into the housing I knew it came from easily and I didn't want to push it, the fan connector easily fitted and the cap sensor plug easily went in the other, I didn't notice they are all JST connectors and could be fitted wrong.
3DGBIRE did also mention the routing of the fan cable can affect the sensor performance.
The moral of this fix is
it was always the front fan on this machine. the original slowly died and I cleaned it and got another month of work but the issue was slowly returning, the new fan fitted would have fixed it.
3DGBIRE did a service and a great quick turn around, I can't fault them on their service and a decent price.
I will now go and avoid all my co-workers and hang my head in shame.
bd