Ultimaker 3 single extrusion Simplify3D profile

[fabreax 15]

Hi,

I'm looking for a "good" Ultimaker 3 single extrusion profile for S3D.

I have seen the file from @neotko : https://ultimaker.com/en/community/23257-simplify3d-profile-for-ultimaker-3-basic-pla-pla-work-in-progress

The UM2 S3D official profile is better.

UM3 official profile :

There is an issue with the retractation. I have tried coast at end 1mm, 2mm and 4mm. I have tried wipe 1mm.

The retractation with the UM2 and the official S3D profile is far less visible.

Do you have settings to share ?

Thanks

[neotko 1,406]

Well I haven't touched my um3 for 3 months now, is i. Bit and peaces atm.

As far as I can tell. Um2 hotend can control the blobs better because it needs less pressure to extrude than the um3 cores. Um3 cores have a more controlled hotzone, to avoid dripping but in exchange of that you need more force to push the same mm3. So, more pressure from filament backlash, ergo, more blobs.

I really haven't touch the profiles much since I changed all the cores and extruders to 1.75 & bondtech.

I would play with wipe retract distance to control that. Also thing that s3d on um2 doesn't use acceleration jerk tricks to print like my s3d profile or Cura profiles. Um3 needs lower acceleration due weight (and other stuff that um should have improved imo). So, for single print, um2 beats um3 at any print.

Maybe you could get a cura setting and debug how to replicate it on s3d. I was gonna do that but I found the printer too boring. If um ever allows to change the firmware easy of the um3 I might get back to mod it, and make some profiles. I just can't (is beyond my patience and I can't make anything profitable on that speed range) print as slow as default settings allow to.

But if they open the firmware for easy changes without ssh or linux knowhow, I'm in.

[fabreax 15]

Thanks for your answer ! I'm disapointed with the UM3 in single extrusion :( That was not written on the product page ...

I'm using your profile for the acceleration and it seems to be better (no toc toc sound when the head moves). My retractation settings :

Have you tried higher retractation/coast at end/wipe settings ?

[neotko 1,406]

I'm away till tomorrow but will check my old profiles folder.

[fabreax 15]

I'm away till tomorrow but will check my old profiles folder.

Thank you so much . I will try 40mm/s retractation instead of 25mm/s ...

[neotko 1,406]

The problem of the noises comes from

https://ultimaker.com/en/community/39416-simplify3d-retraction-bug-that-can-drive-you-nuts

To fix it, s3d should freaking read my mails (I don't know why I even bother with the slicer programmers).

To fix it.. You should rewrite the tool change script, not hard... But too bored to do it.. Post a link to your profile fff and I will try to fix it. S3D is nice but they have their own vision (just like Cura). Anyhow S3D 99% of the time doesn't lissen, and cura team sometimes actually does.

So... You know, nothing is perfect

Edited March 23, 2017 by Guest

[fabreax 15]

It seems that in my profile, the second print core heatup. I only want a single print with the first print core. Could you help me to remove code about the second print core ?

My profile (based on yours) : https://we.tl/KIQAdMe5Pv

[fabreax 15]

40mm/s retractation instead of 25mm/s is far better ! I will reduce coast at end (currently 1mm) and wipe (currently 1mm) :

[fearoffish 0]

Hey @fabreax, did you get any closer with your profile?

[fabreax 15]

Hey @fabreax, did you get any closer with your profile?

I will send you my profile by PM.

[titaniumapple 4]

Hey @fabreax, did you get any closer with your profile?

I will send you my profile by PM.

Hi, could you send it to me too please? Thanks!

[fabreax 15]

I'm sorry, I have replaced my 3 UM3 by UM2+, much more reliable !

[titaniumapple 4]

I'm sorry, I have replaced my 3 UM3 by UM2+, much more reliable !

 

Fair enough, yeah UM3 is a nightmare!

Is there a respository/website where people upload working Ultimaker material profiles?