Jump to content
SeattleDavid

One layer closure of chimney-like structure

Recommended Posts

Posted · One layer closure of chimney-like structure

Cura is generating incorrect GCode. It is closing off an area that should be open.

 

I have what is essentially a duct/chimney running from the bottom of a structure into the module of it. The structure is much like a house, and the duct/chimney is open on the ground level and runs up into the structure, where it dead-ends. The intent is to have a cavity in the structure that can be accessed from the opening in the floor.

 

The duct is being rendered mostly correctly. But on one specific layer the extruder is filling in the duct, adding a one layer floor, complete with supports.

 

I have triple checked the STL file using an STL viewer and there is no floor inside of the duct.

 

I can find no plausible reason why this floor within the duct is being added gratuitously.

 

I have tried simplifying the design br cropping out walls and other features of the block. When I remove one particular wall...located far far away...then the problem ceases to happen.

 

Any thoughts about this? Is it a known bug, or does some situation cause this?

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Posted · One layer closure of chimney-like structure

Could you please save the Cura project (File -> Save) and attach the resulting .3mf file to this thread. Thanks.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Posted · One layer closure of chimney-like structure

Attached are files. I have reduced my model as much as I can while the problem still reproduces.

 

In the first image you will see highlighted in yellow what the model looks like on the bottom In the second image you see what Cura is producing for the first layer. Notice that the hole is missing in Cura's slicing of the first layer.

 

Notice in the model a line that is on the right-facing wall about 10% up from the floor. I'd this line is deleted, the problem disappears. However, I have carefully looked inside the model and it is not forming a floor or compartment...it's just a line. Similarly, deleting other structures like the girl on the end also causes the problem to disappear.

 

Also attached are two partial X-Ray views showing that there is no floor or structure that intersects the "chimney with the curved top" to create any sort of a floor.

 

-----

 

Any help that can be offered with this would be appreciated. I have spent a long time on this. The actual model is very complex, and recreating it would take a month or so...so I would love to know what either the problem is or what the workaround is. Do I have a bad setting? Is this a known bug?

 

 

1573085018_CPD2019-11-25X-3d.thumb.png.2b5ec6238ba51598e4f3dad4f9aad31e.png 1480059684_CPD2019-11-25X.thumb.png.322fdbe94f1d54963eb2df843462d6d5.png

616745221_CPD2019-11-25X-X1.thumb.png.ad587bd12a18574bdc20e192b9f6c6b0.png

861612741_CPD2019-11-25X-X2.thumb.png.da27a4a617c60c45fa5f00becabe0f3c.png

CPD 2019-11-25X.3mf CPD 2019-11-25X.stl CPD 2019-11-25X.skp.zip

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Posted · One layer closure of chimney-like structure

The model has a lot incorrect normals. Even one that on the same face. I recall reading somewhere that cura doens't affect by normals, but I guess I read wrong.

Here is the model after fixing the normals.

 

image.thumb.png.5e0ee70527affb1fb9bb99f9dd5dc988.png

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Posted · One layer closure of chimney-like structure

As @alexjx says, the problem appears to be with the model's normals. If you install the Mesh Tools plugin from the Marketplace, you have an option to fix model normals from within Cura. Here's your model, twice. The one on the right has had its normals fixed by the plugin, the other, not.

 

Screenshot_2019-11-26_07-30-41.thumb.png.a46ca7dccf6de0884db15bf2015eef08.png

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Posted · One layer closure of chimney-like structure

Wow!

 

I can't express enough gratitude. I spent days struggling with this. I didn't know about this tool, I will get it.

 

I appreciate your time, the help diagnosing it, and sharing this tool which I didn't know about or know that I needed.

 

Thanks again.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

Welcome to the Ultimaker Community of 3D printing experts. Visit the following links to read more about our Terms of Use or our Privacy Policy. Thank you!