Motion shaping by cura

[serj_ku 0]

Hello, i prefer to use Cura slicer it's powerfull and I think function that I propose can be adding in furure.

 

I wanna ask about motion shaper (input shaping (aka rrf input shaping), maybe it's have alredy exist (can't find it).

 

This technic reduse ringing on parts (first look i can find here) person "DigitalVision" modify gcode only and get nice and clean print, so cura slicer make the code. I'm not a mathematical or programmer maybe it's easy to add this technique to it.

 

 

[ahoeben 1,760]

I'll admit that I don't know much about RRF, but from a cursory look Input Shaping is done mostly in the firmware. The only change that needs to be made (after calibration of the parameters) is adding an M593 gcode command to the start gcode snippet:

https://duet3d.dozuki.com/Wiki/M593

[serj_ku 0]

28 minutes ago, ahoeben said:

I'll admit that I don't know much about RRF, but from a cursory look Input Shaping is done mostly in the firmware. The only change that needs to be made (after calibration of the parameters) is adding an M593 gcode command to the start gcode snippet:

https://duet3d.dozuki.com/Wiki/M593

At now yes, they add it in frimware, but they don't use close loop control system (like klipper). So i think it's can be adding in gcode by slicer it's can open this technique to 8 bit boards and so on. 

 

In start it was only gcode modify: 

 

The specific parameters for the correction above was f_n=40.4 Hz, zeta=0.

I got these results without making any FW changes. I instead abused the motion planner by feeding it G-code that simulated the required motion profiles. I think the results look pretty interesting and this is probably worth pursuing further.

[serj_ku 0]

 

 

Here is good preview. And math here by Oskar Linde (DigitalVision).

 

About calibration (to find good frequency) can be use manual klipper calibration it's no need accelerometer to measure it

Edited March 22, 2022 by serj_ku

[ahoeben 1,760]

I am afraid that doing this by preprocessing gcode (as opposed to inside the motion planner in the firmware), it will greatly increase the size of gcode files, which will have adverse effects on especially 8 bit boards.

[3dprntz 3]

When are we going to get this update to the Ultimaker printers? I know that we can print slowly to improve quality, but also, the marlin update provides input shaping on all printers now.