Is CURA supposed to reduce the file size of a part without any warning?

[celso-santos 10]

I just think that I have lost days of printing, a lot of material and a lot work time after I discovered that CURA, without any warning reduces the file size of a model when it is larger than 223x223x205mm that is the available print size of my Ultimaker 2+. The awful part is that sometimes it shows the real part size with gray stripes, making sure that the size is not correct. Some other times, and do not ask me why, the part shows colored yellow and fits the plate.

To make sure that I am not crazy, I drew a square solid prism that measures 243x243 x150mm and dropped inside CURA. It immediately accepted the solid showing the part colored yellow and stating its new size: 184.5x113.9x184.5. A reduction of 24,07%!!! Why? Without any warning?

I don't know what you think, but for me this is a really serious flaw and a bad behavior, because we cannot trust the information delivered by the software. The worst part is that sometimes CURA shows the real size of the part with its image grayed out in stripes.

Has anyone experimente something like this?

Am I doing something wrong?

thanks

Celso

[Labern 718]

This Can be turned off in the settings under General, Scale Large Models.

It should Warn you that the size was reduced. Well it used to.

[celso-santos 10]

This Can be turned off in the settings under General, Scale Large Models.

It should Warn you that the size was reduced. Well it used to.

 

Thanks Labern. There should be a big warning stating "Model scaled to fit the printing are", or something like that. In my case, sometimes CURA scaled the big files, sometimes not, making me think that I was crazy.

I also think that this feature should be off by default. If we want to increase or reduce the model size this should be done voluntarily.

[Labern 718]

There Used To be that warning. Maybe there is a bug so its not displaying it.

Not sure why it would slice sometimes and not others. It maybe a bug also or maybe the print was moved to the side a bit?

[nilrog 96]

I also think that this feature should be off by default. If we want to increase or reduce the model size this should be done voluntarily.

 

Welcome to the club...you are not the only one who thinks so...

[nallath 583]

Scale to fit is disabled by default. This was changed about 2 months ago, so this is in the 2.5 release

[nilrog 96]

Eehh...the current latest version is 2.4...so saying that this was changed 2 months ago is not true...maybe...depending on your release schedule...you could say that this will be changed in 2 months

[nallath 583]

Eehh...the current latest version is 2.4...so saying that this was changed 2 months ago is not true...maybe...depending on your release schedule...you could say that this will be changed in 2 months

 

Uh. Yes it is. I just looked at the commit that changed that line of code. The 2.4 release was in beta for a long time and someone fixed this on the master branch.

[nilrog 96]

Cura 2.4 still automatically scales large and small models...I just deleted my prefs and launched it again and those settings are enabled...so in the big world this is still an issue...until 2.5 is released. Whatever is changed in your development version does not count as fixed to the majority of the users

[nallath 583]

Whatever is changed in your development version does not count as fixed to the majority of the users

 

 

Scale to fit is disabled by default. This was changed about 2 months ago, so this is in the 2.5 release

 

I think i already mentioned that it was not in 2.4

[nilrog 96]

I think i already mentioned that it was not in 2.4

 

True, but you also said that it was changed two months ago...which is not true...since there is no Cura released with this function disabled by default...so this is not fixed yet

That said...i'm glad that Ultimaker finally came to your senses and realized that this was a very dangerous thing to have enabled by default

[nallath 583]

The source is always released So run it from source and you have it seconds after it's committed.