Hey Bas,
I think the problem lies elsewhere since different UM2 owners with seemingly identical feeders, still have very different results.
I suspect a firmware problem or a combination of bad pulleys and bent rods. I wanted to test the rods for ages but now that my 3DR Delta build is finished and I need to fine tune it, I got sidetracked.
However, for the firmware idea, a few posts ago I asked around about the combination of firmwares used. But in order to structure the data a bit more, I have started a new thread/poll. I see there are 12 people following this thread so please be so kind and vote here:
http://umforum.ultimaker.com/index.php?/topic/8336-um2-top-surface-firmware-poll/