Jump to content
Ultimaker Community of 3D Printing Experts
exforma23

Why don't people recommend Hairspray for PLA?

Recommended Posts

I'm new to the UM3 and have a lot of experience with ABS and hairspray for bed adhesion with a prior printer. Since I got the UM3 I've been been printing PLA and have been less than satisfied with how reliable pva glue is. I tried the gluestick, schmearing it around etc. thin coats, thick coat. I tried a 10/1 mix of old fashioned Elmer's glue brushed on.

Keep in mind that I prefer to avoid using a brim if at all possible. Ideally, I prefer to set up my geometry and print settings so that I have no clean-up whatsoever.

Finally, just for the heck of it, I tried the old can of "Aqua Net Extra Super Hold" that I still have from my ABS prints...

EUREKA!

Bed adhesion far superior to glue options, Print is glass smooth on the bottom with not schmear marks. Just pop in into the fridge after is done and it just falls off the glass.

Why is this not the method of choice for use with PLA?

I can't see any downside.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The only downside is that it can stick way too much to the point of actually chipping the glass if isn't properly cold.

I use for pla when I need max fans, since my fans are much more powerful than the um2/um3 ones.

I use this trick to remove the pla/platec/flexibles after using a coat of hairspray

https://ultimaker.com/en/community/33206-greentec-pla-easy-removal-after-hairspray

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

We do, you must be lookig at the wrong threads:)! I have used PLA/hairspray for 3 years + on a glass bed. I find actually that it is easy to remove a piece even with the plate being warm. I can take it off the bed, set at 60-65, lay it on a table and after 30-60secs it will come off. Ofc that will be affected by your nozzle to plate distance and removing the plate from the printer straightaway has shrinkage implications.

And of course it is so easy to apply, has good longevity and is easy to clean off 8)

Edited by Guest

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I was about to say that neotko *does* promote hair spray and has a video of it. But he was faster. :)

I use the "salt method": after cleaning the glass plate with water, gently wipe it with a tissue moistened with salt water. Gently keep wiping while it dries into a thin, almost invisible mist of salt stuck to the plate.

For me, this gives excellent bonding of colorFabb and Ultimaker PLA, and still good but not perfect bonding of ICE PLA.

When hot, it bonds like cyanoacrylate. But when cold, the models come off by themselves and are sitting totally loose on the plate.

For the full manual with photos, see the PDF file at:

https://www.uantwerpen.be/nl/personeel/geert-keteleer/manuals/

For ABS this does not work at all: it starts foaming and splattering, I don't know why (maybe because of the water in the salt?)

For PET it works a bit: it reduces bonding strenght a little bit, but makes it much easier to remove the models after cooling down: they don't get stuck to the plate anymore.

I also tried the dilluted wood glue method for PET: it gave a super bonding, but once tore a piece of glass out of the bed. So I am a bit reluctant to use that, if not absolutely necessary.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks for all the input!

This is definitely plenty more options to think about (especially neotko's glass cleaner exothermic deal)

I've done about 5 prints with my aqua net and it's working perfectly and falling off when it gets down to temp in the freezer. I am, however, noticing the warp with the rapid cooling.

 

I think I'll buy a 2nd glass build plate so that I can pull out a build and set it aside to patiently cool. Hopefully, this will mitigate the rapid cool warp effects. This way I can keep the printer humming.

I just can't stand to see it sitting idle. :-)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I will do a write about something I'm testing atm. I bought Neoceram glass plate, on a shop that sells custom size and 4mm. So far I'm just amazed. I can get greentec to stick without any hairspray, this glass has the interesting property of not changing of size when heating up. I will write on other post about this, but so far 3 days of production, zero issues. But for pla I need to put some windowasher (plain water also works) to release it without doing force (because I want it to last as much as possible).

So.. Amazed so far by this neoceram glass (is used on fireplaces).

Oh other advantage very important, it can withstand a 800C heat impact, and doesn't loose integrity like tempered glass when exposed to heat/cold. So, so far, amazing. But this needs more testing.

Oh also, is cheaper than UM glass...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

noetko,

Fireplace glass that I have used (on my fireplace), on a microscopic level, is porous. The claim is that it allows for better direct heat transfer while also being more heat resistant.

I wonder if Neoceram glass is. I would expect that would help with adhesion.

One thing I will say about having "bulletproof" adhesion with hairspray is that there is noticeable improvement in overall print quality throughout the print. With PVA, I was experiencing less than optimal adhesion. It was most noticeable in the support layers. Since the support layers have very little surface contact, l could see slight "rounding" of sharp corners. I wouldn't have known that this was a clue of not great adhesion until I tried the hairspray. With the hairspray, support corners are sharp and remain sharp for the full height. Now I see how it's supposed to look.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Exactly that rounding is what I get on greentec when I don't use hairspray. For pla I seen that when using fans at full very close to the bed. Indeed hairspray is a very easy and reliable solution IMO.

Also indeed it has a slightly 'frosted' texture. Doesn't fell by hand so the texture must be really really small.

IMG_5501.thumb.JPG.16c180180e41d9d674a0e05c0603fe49.JPG

IMG_5501.thumb.JPG.16c180180e41d9d674a0e05c0603fe49.JPG

Edited by Guest

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think I'll buy a 2nd glass build plate so that I can pull out a build and set it aside to patiently cool. Hopefully, this will mitigate the rapid cool warp effects.  This way I can keep the printer humming.

I just can't stand to see it sitting idle. :-)

 

Yup I have thought about that but think it will take longer for that 2nd plate to get up to temoerature. If I am doing a production run, maybe 50 pieces, I cannot wait too long in between each print. I take out the plate on completion, room is circa 22 degrees ambient, and lay it on a glass table. The plate is down to circa 45 degrees in say 5-6 mins and off the piece pops and the plate is back up to 60/65 5 or so minutes later - the first thing I do when the print completes is to raise the bed temp up to 90+ ready to warm the plate quickly when it is put back.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I can't see any downside.

Health and safety. The hazardous material measurement people loved it, as they had finally something harmful to measure in our office.

There is also an possible case of a house exploding because of excessive hairspray usage in a 3D printer. But I don't think that's what really happened there.

And hairspray isn't made with the intent to be heated to these temperatures for prolonged times, so no idea what gasses it would emit then.

And then there is the possible effect on axis, belts, bearings. Can't be good if it goes where oil should be going.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

 

I can't see any downside.

Health and safety. The hazardous material measurement people loved it, as they had finally something harmful to measure in our office.

There is also an possible case of a house exploding because of excessive hairspray usage in a 3D printer. But I don't think that's what really happened there.

And hairspray isn't made with the intent to be heated to these temperatures for prolonged times, so no idea what gasses it would emit then.

And then there is the possible effect on axis, belts, bearings. Can't be good if it goes where oil should be going.

 

Hairspray is just pva. Also, come on men, exploding house!? Did you even read the full article regarding that incident? The guy had flash paper...

Also, you don't need at all to apply it inside the printer, just get a paper towel, hairspray it, and clean the bed with that while is humid.

But indeed. Using ANY stuff without ventilation is dangerous. But is more dangerous to not read the warning signs in RED of the hairspray cans...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I've been using Aquanet since I upgraded my UMO to a heated bed. Works well enough that once I tried it, I quite looking for something better. My use is mostly ABS now, but have used it with PLA also with great results. Only takes the lightest dusting on consumer window glass, before mounting the glass. Multiple glass panes are a good idea. If I want continuous running, I pre heat a spare glass in the toaster oven on low heat. The printer is now located in the garage so fumes are less of health issue be they from the filament or spray.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

×

Important Information

Terms of Use Privacy Policy